Sign in or signup

5,511 active users!!Bandwidth
SUNDAY
AUG 20, 2017
Home
NewsSITE
Events & Blogs
New Audio & Video
Broadcasters
Local & Church Finder
Webcast LIVE NOW!
Sermons by Bible
Sermons by Topic
Sermons by Speaker
Sermons by Date
Staff Picks
CommentsALL -18 min
Top Sermons
VideosPDFs
Daily Log
PhotosNew Stuff!
Stores
Online Bible
Hymnal
Daily Reading
Our Services
Submit Sermon
Members Only

Breaking News Home | All | Religion | Society | Tech | Choice | Fridays | SA Newsroom
FRONT PAGE  |  8/20/2017
THURSDAY, JAN 10, 2008  |  9 comments
Evolutionists at war over altruism's origins
An intellectual war of words has broken out between two of the world's leading evolutionists. Oxford University's Richard Dawkins and Harvard's Edward Wilson have gone head to head over the evolution of altruism in the animal kingdom, and whether it can have come about as a result of something called group selection.

The subject matter of their dispute is social insects, particularly ants, which display a supreme form of altruism in that sterile workers lay down their lives for the benefit of their fertile colleagues in the colony.

Conventional Darwinian theory could not really explain why one individual should sacrifice its own life, and its precious genes, for the benefit of another individual, unless it could be viewed in terms of group selection, when indi-viduals do it for the benefit of the colony or the species. ...


CLICK HERE to Read Entire Article
news.independent.co.uk

Was Darwin Right? Part 1
  START  
  Recommended sermons | more..
•  Genesis: Reclaiming Culture • Ken Ham | 5/22/2003
•  Genesis and the Culture War • Ken Ham | 2/13/2017
•  Was Darwin Right? Part 1Dr. Terry Mortenson | 1/15/2009
•  Answers Academy: Big BangJason Lisle | 6/1/2005

   03/14/15  |  Another One Bites the Dust • 3 comments
   03/11/15  |  God Doesn't Want Matt Chandler to be Your Pastor • 21 comments
   01/08/14  |  Christian Post: Warning, this article may offend many Christians • 93 comments
   01/01/14  |  Michelle Obama praises lesbian TV anchor • 18 comments
   12/29/13  |  U.S. Slams 'Conservative Gender Norms' • 377 comments
MORE RELATED ( ) NEWS | MORE..
   08/19/17  |  Second vehicle attack: five terror suspects 'wearing suicide... • 5 comments
   08/19/17  |  20 seconds ‘all it took’: Oregon man left partially blind by... • 6 comments
   08/18/17  |  Islamic State claims responsibility for Barcelona van attack • 8 comments
   08/18/17  |  NI judge dismisses same-sex marriage cases • 2 comments
   08/17/17  |  SermonAudio Tip: Visually Interpret Your Sermons With PowerClips!
OTHER CHOICE NEWS | MORE..
   08/18/17  |  Feedback Friday for 08-18-17
   08/17/17  |  SermonAudio Tip: Visually Interpret Your Sermons With PowerClips!
   08/11/17  |  Feedback Friday for 08-11-17
   08/07/17  |  SermonAudio Tip: Automated Sermon Uploads From Existing Feeds • 2 comments
   08/04/17  |  Feedback Friday for 08-04-17
MORE SPECIAL | MORE..
   08/20/17  |  Jews are leaving France in record numbers • 19 comments
   08/20/17  |  Iceland Down syndrome abortions called 'a tragedy' • 8 comments
   08/20/17  |  UN Boss Urges Schools to Promote Wealth Redistribution & Control • 6 comments
   08/20/17  |  Duke University removes Lee statue from chapel • 16 comments
   08/19/17  |  Here's a Look at Gov't Efforts to Advance Transgender Identity • 5 comments
OTHER RECENT NEWS | MORE..
COMMENTS | show all | add new  
    Sorting Order:  
· Page 1 ·  Found: 9 user comment(s)
News Item1/11/08 12:30 PM
Mike | New York  Find all comments by Mike
Ha! wrote:
Mike
Please don't give them ideas!
They struggle to explain why despite this wonderful and mysterious organising principle latent in matter called "evolution" people are as bad as they are, when they are supposed to be getting better and better - The ascent of man and all that...
And there you go giving them a plausible explanation which fits right in with their God forsaken beliefs!
But then they would indeed be contradicting their own theory, which is that evolution/natural selection improves the species. And they would have to see themselves as degenerating, which their massive egos would not allow them to do. They won't use my explanation, never fear.
9

News Item1/11/08 12:17 PM
Ha!  Find all comments by Ha!
Mike wrote:
....The Darwinian, because of his stand, and if he were honest, would conclude that self sacrifice should lead to extinction, or at least a degeneration of the species. But of course he doesn't. Why is that?
Mike

Please don't give them ideas!

They struggle to explain why despite this wonderful and mysterious organising principle latent in matter called "evolution" people are as bad as they are, when they are supposed to be getting better and better - The ascent of man and all that...

And there you go giving them a plausible explanation which fits right in with their God forsaken beliefs!

8

News Item1/11/08 12:11 PM
Mike | New York  Find all comments by Mike
" Conventional Darwinian theory could not really explain why one
individual should sacrifice its own life, and its precious genes,
for the benefit of another individual, unless it could be viewed
in terms of group selection, when indi-viduals do it for the benefit
of the colony or the species. "

This self-sacrifice is, of course, an act of superior behavior. One would then have to question how, in the Darwinian view, the destruction of these "precious genes" could increase the quality of the remaing "colony or the species." If the very quality of "precious genes" that benefits the species ceases to exist, it cannot be passed on. The more that these self sacrifices occur, the less are there that remain to be included in the gene pool. The Darwinian, because of his stand, and if he were honest, would conclude that self sacrifice should lead to extinction, or at least a degeneration of the species. But of course he doesn't. Why is that?

7

News Item1/11/08 11:43 AM
John | San Jose, CA  Find all comments by John
" Conventional Darwinian theory could not really explain why one
individual should sacrifice its own life, and its precious genes,
for the benefit of another individual, unless it could be viewed
in terms of group selection, when indi-viduals do it for the benefit
of the colony or the species. "

Isn't this rich? Whether they realize it or not, they're witnessing
a miniature reflection of the gospel (John 15:13) within their own
created universe (which even though it's fallen, is still full of
God's glory--Isaiah 6:3)...and they're still trying to explain it
away as nothing more than some mechanistic biological process.

Reminds me of all those gay men trying to find Lot's door shortly
after the angels blinded them back in Genisis 19.

6

News Item1/10/08 6:56 PM
Weapon of Mass Instruction | Dehvastating Truth  Find all comments by Weapon of Mass Instruction
Bunch of apes
5

News Item1/10/08 6:45 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
Two alpha males in a life-or-death struggle for dominance over the troop.
4

News Item1/10/08 6:28 PM
Jhawk44  Find all comments by Jhawk44
This is one of the craziest war of babbling fools I've seen.
3

News Item1/10/08 6:20 PM
GK  Find all comments by GK
Dawkins is one of the most arrogant self opinionated people I have ever heard

He has no idea of what it is he is criticising,and when you listen to his straw man theology it's easy to see why

hasn't a clue!!

2

News Item1/10/08 6:09 PM
Allan | New Zealand  Find all comments by Allan
"His 'group selection' terminology is misleading, and his distinction between 'kin selection' and 'individual direct selection' is empty."

Dawkins always seems to have that kind of tone when dealing with anyone who has any opinion different than his own. The attitude of "How silly they can't possibly be right because I am"

Of course, he believes he's at the top of the evolutionary tree that's mutated by chance for millions of years.

Me - I'm descended from an original designed human. It's true I have mutations over several hundred generations. But I'm more like a piece of designed machinery than an explosion in a factory causing a mechanical mess. I even have a kind of instruction manual for appropriate use.

So maybe I might have an opinion worthy of contradicting Dawkins'. That would be "My designer disagrees with your conclusion".

/rant

1
There are a total of 9 user comments displayed | add new comment |Subscribe to these comments
Last PostTotal
Jews are leaving France in record numbers
jim lincoln from nebraska: " dr. tim this thread has me a little bit confused...."
-14 min 19 
Duke University removes Lee statue from chapel
mike from new york: " jim lincoln robert e lee wasn't all that respected in the..."
-22 min 16 
UN Boss Urges Schools to Promote Wealth Redistribution &...
jim lincoln from nebraska: "you, mean this one, i.e.? abraham lincoln said or, ..."
-30 min 


Lacombe, Alberta, Canada
Lacombe Free Reformed Church

Play! | More

Dr. Steven J. Lawson
PowerClip: Jonathan Edwards

Kinetic Type Sermon Clips
Video DVD
SermonAudio Classics
Play! | MP4 | RSS


Hourly: Bible Study Helps: Benefits
Dr. Michael Barrett
Faith Free Presbyterian...
Staff Picks..

Shawn Reynolds
From A Pit Of Clay To The Rock

Grace Particular Baptist
Sunday Service
Transcript!Play! | MP3

E. A. Johnston
The Gospel Is For The Needy

Evangelism Awakening
Special Meeting
Play! | MP3

Event: The Beauty and Glory of the Reformation
Puritan Reformed Theological

SPONSOR | 1,500+

SPONSOR




                   
The Gospel is not so much a miracle as a marvel. ... Martin Luther

Gospel of John
Cities | Local | Personal


MOBILE
iPhone + iPad New!
Church App
Android New!
Church App
Kindle + Nook
Chromecast TV
Apple TV
ROKU TV
Amazon Fire TV New!
Apple Watch
Android Wear
Kindle Reader


HELP
Knowledgebase
Broadcasters
Listeners
Q&A
Uploading Sermons
Uploading Videos
Webcasting
Tips & Tricks
YouTube Screencasts

FOLLOW
Weekly Newsletter
Staff Picks Feed
SA Newsroom New!
RSS | Twitter | Facebook
SERVICES | ALL
Church Finder | Info
MP3 Play & Download
Mobile Apps
Podcast | Video Support
Live Webcasting
Events Support
Transcription
PowerClips
Business Cards New!
SOLO | MINI | Domain
Favorites | QR Codes
Online Donations
24x7 Radio Stream
INTEGRATION
Embed Codes
Goodies
WordPress
Twitter
Facebook
Logos | e-Sword | BW
JSON API

BATCH
Transfer Agent
Protected Podcasts
Auto-Upload Sermons
Upload via FTP
Upload via Dropbox
Picasa
ABOUT US
The largest and most trusted library of audio sermons from conservative churches and ministries worldwide.

Our Services | Articles of Faith
Broadcast With Us
Advertising | Local Ads
CONTACT
info@sermonaudio.com
Support Us | Feedback Fridays | Stories