|
|
USER COMMENTS BY MARTY |
|
|
Page 1 | Page 7 · Found: 211 user comments posted recently. |
| | | |
|
|
2/13/12 8:50 AM |
Marty | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
john anticalvin wrote: Lurker...That's something I really dislike about Calvinism. When the God says He loves the whole world and whosoever will may come, Calvinist will change His words to mean He didn't love the "world", only some, and "whosever"only means a few. When God says faith is not a work, the Calvinist says it is but because it's God who forces the faith, it's not a work that people do. Calvinist don't seem to understand that faith is not a work at all whether it's an action of man or God. world in english is based on multiple underlying options when translated. I'd suggest a lexicon. Also "whosoever" could also apply to those the Holy Spirit regenerates. Also "all men" can apply to everyone or all types and classes of people. you may not like it but learning why we say what we say might be worthwhile. Can read most reformers and puritans or listen on sermonaudio to Francis Nigel Lee or James White etc. lots of reformed guys on here. But ultimately it's a highly interlinked system of doctrine, not able to be taken rationally piece by piece. |
|
|
2/12/12 8:39 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: v 24 reminds us of the context viz. that Paul is still writing about the Jewish controversy about the justice of God in saving believing Gentiles while rejecting unbelieving Jews. Paul is not, and cannot, be attempting to persuade his readers that God pre-selects some to be “vessels of wrath” and others to be “vessels of mercy,” as that would contradict everything He has said about God’s justice. Rather, Paul is emphasizing that God has been extremely patient with those who were “vessels of wrath prepared for destruction” (9:22). These “vessels” were not “prepared sovereignly by God,” but simply “prepared,” or “ready” for destruction because of their own sinfulness. Paul is not saying that only a certain percentage of people are “vessels of wrath.” All people are such vessels prior to their repentance and regeneration, as Paul has made abundantly clear in earlier chapters of Romans.ePaul explains that the reason God was so patient with vessels that were so worthy of His judgment Admittedly I dont know Greek but v 21 suggests an active act of vessel making for both parties, not just those of mercy. Even more they come from the same lump, a bit like Jacob and his brother. But i'll meditate on your view for the night |
|
|
2/12/12 8:31 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: Faith does not "merit" righteousness! Faith being accounted righteousness is not the same as meriting anything. You are adding to the scriptures. We are back to Romans 4:16 "Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace (not merit!)....." It doesnt merit under the Law but it is an affirmative belief that receives a blessing of righteousness. It isnt nothing on the part of Abraham. |
|
|
2/12/12 8:09 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: Romans 3:28 Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law If faith were a deed of the law then this would not be true. Faith is not a deed of the Law. I agree but it still merits righteousness. Abraham had faith and God counted Him as righteousness. |
|
|
2/12/12 7:49 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: Not to mention that it flies in the face of scripture! Ezekiel 33:11 "Say unto them, As I live, saith the Lord GOD, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live: turn ye, turn ye from your evil ways; for why will ye die, O house of Israel?" Come on guys that's not what we mean by pleasure. His glory and pleasure comes from highlighting His mercy by using justice and wrath... Few verses down Romans 9:22, 23. I dont mean sadistic enjoyment. |
|
|
2/12/12 7:07 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: Care to produce a scripture to show that it is the law's fulfillment? How do you read Romans 4:16? viz. "Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace....." Here faith and grace go hand in hand. If faith was of the law, then grace would NOT sit well with it because then it would be deserved! Romans 10:4 with Matthew 5 |
|
|
2/12/12 6:49 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
john anticalvin wrote: Tidbit...I understand there are none righteous under the law. Ems 3:20 says "...by the works of the Law no flesh will be justified in His sight;". However, verse 28 makes it clear "that a man is justified by faith apart from works of the Law." So people can do what is considered good, just not according to the works of the Law. Faith, not being a work, can be performed unto salvation only because then God graciously saves us at faith. Faith is not a work of the law but it is commanded and the law's fulfillment |
|
|
2/12/12 6:05 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: The Romans verse you quoted was RomansThe verse reads "Thou wilt say then unto me, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will?" So I have no idea where your interpretation comes from. And, in any case whoever said that we are born by man's will? You misrepresent again! All I insist on is what the scriptures say viz. "~~~Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace~~~; to the end thepromise might be sure to all the seed; not to that only which is of the law, but to that also which is of the faith of Abraham; who is the father of us all" Romans 4.16 There is nothing here to intimate that somehow faith is a work or meritorious. Quite the contrary the beggars arms receiving the bounty magnifies the grace of the giver! This calvinist witch hunt against those who themselves believe as though they had committed a crime is wholly unwarranted from the bible. If you have any verse or passage which demonstrates that faith is ever a work bring it forward. The Romans verse is meaningful to reformed people because it highlights God's selective mercy. He has appointed some to life and some to death for His pleasure and glory. If both could have saving faith, there'd be no need for this statement by the damned. |
|
|
2/12/12 5:29 PM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
john anticalvin wrote: Lurker...then I really don't get why if someone says they were saved by faith that a Calvinist will be quick to accuse the person of believing in salvation by works of the flesh. Salvation by merit is what we mean by that. If faith is a gift then it is not a human work. Also, faith is a good work because it is (1) commanded of all men and (2) the fulfillment of the Law. Also I agree with man below that Adam had knowledge of good and evil but a sin nature to always choose evil. |
|
|
2/12/12 11:55 AM |
Marty | | Usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: Show me a Christian who says that one does not need to be born again, or that it is done by the will of God. Prove to me that faith is a gift of God. Romans 9.19 I doubt you understand this. Sure we have a free will as to whether we come to Christ or not. Were you made a robot before you came to Christ? Who, other than you says that man has to achieve something that God cannot? You appear very confused as to what the opposing party actually believes. So instead of misrepresentation why don't you take the time to read and consider? I made no mention of robots. I made mention of nature, dead sin nature. A nature that seeks nothing righteous, hating God. But please tell me what that verse in Romans is meant to achieve. What is Ephesians 2:8,9 meant to achieve? ... What about Ezekiel 36:26 and Jeremiah 24:7? Notice the "I" not the "we" or "us." and how can you have faith if you're not born again? Was your first birth your free will choice too? |
|
|
2/12/12 9:34 AM |
marty | | usa | | | |
|
Thread closed Report abuse
|
Calvinism is false wrote: You don't have a monopoly on grace. You do have a weird construction of it which you claim is superior to the plain teaching of the bible. So we don't need to be born again? Or can it be done by the will of man? I suppose faith isn't a gift from God?Same old pelagian/cassian/arminian, works-based religion. And Romans 9:19 is in the bible why (?) if we can just have free will in our faith decision? And am I to believe that man can achieve something that God can not? Can man overcome his nature? Obviously God can not contradict Himself or lie. But man, so sovereign and powerful can do all things... awful. |
|
|
1/14/12 6:47 PM |
Marty | | usa | | | |
|
Add new comment Reply to comment Report abuse
|
Jim Lincoln wrote: At least one who has noted that, [URL=http://townhall.com/columnists/michaelmedved/2012/01/04/rise_of_paul_power_only_helps_obama/page/full/]]]Rise of "Paul Power" Only Helps Obama[/URL]. All I can say is that, the Republican menagerie, makes me glad that I am an Independent. Mr. Jim Lincoln, who would have thought that you'd be guided by pragmatism in your opinions on politics. Well, at least you have one thing in common with the Street Preacher (i.e. dislike of Ron Paul without reference to the bible). Is following the law of the land such a bad thing? Is it so bad to hate rent-seeking? Is it so bad to have a limited civil minister, just like God intended? |
|
|
1/13/12 10:32 PM |
marty | | usa | | | |
|
Add new comment Reply to comment Report abuse
|
Kevin Boling wrote: Re: Dr. Ron Paul - his cure is worse than the disease So, better to elect statist idolaters? Men who love covetousness? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|