The Shorter Catechism question
this week is, what is forbidden in the Second Commandment? The
answer is, the Second Commandment forbiddeth the worshipping of
God by images or any other way not appointed in His Word. And so the Second Commandment,
of course, forbiddeth the worshipping of God by things that we devise.
images here is not just those graven, carved things that many
people throughout the ages, throughout history, have made either to
worship directly as if it is God in itself or as a picture
of what they like to think of or how they have thought of the
one true God which if you make a picture of how you think of
him you have just made a infinite reduction of who he is, because
who God is in himself is the real God, and what we think of
him is far beneath, and so the only way to have right thoughts
about the real God is to think his thoughts after him, to be
taught by him from his word. And so the language of forbidding
the worshiping of God by images means really anything that comes
from us, anything that is an imitation or a copy. God has
not actually given us what He looks like. The most He has done,
of course, is his divine son, who is the exact imprint of his
nature, and he has added to himself a human nature, but the human
nature by itself is not the divine son. The divine son is now the
God-man, and he is God from all eternity. And you can't make
a picture, of course, of the divine son if you were to make
a picture just of his humanity. That would be an ancient church
history called Nestorianism, in which the nature of the human
nature of Christ is separated from the divine personhood or
the divine nature of the Lord Jesus Christ. So sometimes you'll
hear people say, well, there is a real human Jesus, so we
could use images of him. Well, the real human Jesus, neither
in his life before his death nor in his resurrection, gave
to his church to worship him by use of any image of himself,
for one. Number two, We do not have any
actual images of the Lord Jesus Christ, so any purported images
are a lie. And number three, of course,
is Nestorianism. Even if we had photos of the
Lord Jesus Christ, it would be Nestorian to use the photo in
the worship because the photo can capture reflections of light
off of the body that the divine son has in his human nature. And so it's kind of this tiny
little component, and we would put ourselves entirely out of
proportion if our idea of the sun is affected by these photos
or is affected by pictures, which may be one of the reasons why
when we hear a sermon like the one we heard, in the Lord's Day
Morning Sermon, and we hear about the divinity of the Son. In our
particular context, we have much difficulty in the churches grasping
the utter divinity of Christ, that He is very God of very God. Of course, the flesh resists
that idea to begin with, but in our context, We're riding
hundreds of years of gross violations of the Second Commandment, and
the pictures have only gotten more detailed, more vivid, producing
more disproportion in how people think of the Savior towards the
human side, separating, in that Nestorian way, the human nature
of Christ from his divine personhood and from his divine nature. And
of course, any other image that we Have in our mind you should
not think of or or make pictures of the Holy Spirit either using
flames of fire or Wind which you can't see and Jesus makes
that point in in John chapter 3 or even Doves When the scripture
says, he alighted upon Christ as a dove, it's making a theological
comment about the Holy Spirit, not saying that there are these
pneumatophanies where the Holy Spirit shows up like the Ahsoka
bird in in moments in history and takes on physical form as
a dove, that's utter rubbish and would indeed harm our understanding
of God the Holy Spirit as well, so that we would be idolaters
with respect to that person of the Godhead. And of course, God
is not just in any one of the persons. And so if we make a
picture that we are using to represent any one person, we
have blasphemed the Trinity, the triune God, the one living
and true God. is in himself three persons. And so we must not make any images
of any one or of all three of the persons. But then there isn't
just the picturing of God that the second commandment forbids. It's also the worshiping of God
in any other way not appointed in his word. God has given us
his statutes. He has given us his word that
stands for us, that has its official place as the only way that we
can come to worship him. And if we add anything to his
word, if we, and we can use the redundant word, it'll help us
hear where the words are coming, if we super add to his statutes,
that becomes superstitious. And so the idea of superstition
is that we may be able to draw near to God in any way that God
hasn't written for us, in any way that God has not established
for us in his word, established for us in writing. So any way
of drawing near to God, or any way of gaining spiritual knowledge,
or any way of gaining spiritual power, other than that which
God has given us in His Word, which is Himself in His Son,
by His Spirit, according to the Scriptures. Any way of drawing
near to God, any way of thinking about spiritual things, especially
about God himself, but gaining spiritual knowledge at all, any
attempt of having spiritual power at all, apart from God has revealed
in his word, is superstitious. It is a violation of the second
commandment. It would put us in the category,
or at least our actions in the category of the actions of them
that hate me. which is how he speaks about
it in the second commandment, which should break our hearts.
The last thing we would ever want to be, and the last ones
like whom we would ever want to act, are them that hate. our God, the Lord our God, who
has delivered us, so that he may be called for us, Yahweh
your God. And we should be jealous for
him, even as he is rightly jealous for himself. So what is forbidden
in the second commandment? The second commandment forbiddeth
the worshiping of God by images or any other way not appointed
in his word.