Sign in or signup
Radio Streams
SA Radio
24/7 Radio Stream
VCY America
24/7 Radio Stream

My Favorite Things
Home
NewsSITE
Events | Local | Blogs
New Audio | Video | Clips
Broadcasters
Church Finder
Webcast LIVE NOW!
Sermons by Bible
Sermons by Category
Sermons by Topic
Sermons by Speaker
Sermons by Date
Staff Picks
CommentsALL -10 sec
Top Sermons
Daily Log
Photos
Stores
Online Bible
Hymnal
Daily Reading
Our Services
Sermon DashboardNEW
Members Only

Breaking News Home | All | Religion | Society | Tech | Choice | SA Newsroom
FRONT PAGE  |  10/18/2019
SUNDAY, FEB 1, 2009  |  18 comments
Televangelism empire in chaos over family split
Once one of the nation's most popular televangelists, the Rev. Robert H. Schuller is watching his life's work crumble.

The Crystal Cathedral blames the recession for its woes. But it's clear that the elder Schuller's carefully orchestrated leadership transition, planned over a decade, has stumbled badly.

It's a problem common to personality driven ministries. Most have collapsed or been greatly diminished after their founders left the pulpit or died.


CLICK HERE to Read Entire Article
www.sfgate.com

  START  
  Recommended sermons | more..
•  Religion Encounters Worship • Jeff Lyle | 3/12/2006
•  The Church Growing • Richard Caldwell Jr. | 2/11/2004

   03/14/15  |  Another One Bites the Dust • 6 comments
   03/11/15  |  God Doesn't Want Matt Chandler to be Your Pastor • 21 comments
   01/08/14  |  Christian Post: Warning, this article may offend many Christians • 93 comments
   01/01/14  |  Michelle Obama praises lesbian TV anchor • 18 comments
   12/29/13  |  U.S. Slams 'Conservative Gender Norms' • 377 comments
MORE RELATED ( ) NEWS | MORE..
   10/18/19  |  Religion Is on the Decline as More Adults Check ‘None’ • 3 comments
   10/14/19  |  Trump talks religious freedom, Kavanaugh, impeachment at Values... • 7 comments
   10/12/19  |  Beto O’Rourke says churches should lose tax-exempt status for... • 16 comments
   10/11/19  |  In-N-Out Owner Keeps Adding New Bible Verses to Packaging • 6 comments
   10/10/19  |  Planned Parenthood Announces $45 Million Plan To Defeat Trump • 12 comments
OTHER CHOICE NEWS | MORE..
   10/18/19  |  UAE Becomes World's First Country to Restore Iraqi Churches... • 2 comments
   10/18/19  |  Christians risk arrest if they display Bible in Saudi Arabia,... • 1 comments
   10/18/19  |  'Not afraid of burning in hell': Ron Reagan atheist ad airs in... • 2 comments
   10/18/19  |  Religion Is on the Decline as More Adults Check ‘None’ • 3 comments
   10/17/19  |  Kanye's Christian Response to Kim Kardashian's 'Too Sexy' Dress... • 5 comments
OTHER RECENT NEWS | MORE..
COMMENTS | show all | add new  
    Sorting Order:  
· Page 1 ·  Found: 18 user comment(s)
News Item2/4/09 7:16 PM
SBGG | S.Cal  Find all comments by SBGG
Some non-denominational churches are now arguing for a Moses model of leadership (theocratic) where the sheriff picks his possy so t speak. Surprisingly, these are often dispensational churches... and not so surprisingly there are increases reports of pastoral abuse due to lack of biblical oversight. I believe it's the Calvary Chapel movement that teaches that the people murmered against Moses in the Exodus thus giving example that a congregational governament is not pragmatic.
18

News Item2/4/09 2:51 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
Jim, well I see no place where elder selection by committee is sanctioned, either. That it "works" for IHCC proves nothing. Papal absolutism "works" too, depending on how one defines the term "work."

Congregational choice of their elders is republican, not "democratic" as practiced in strict congregationalism.

What is the Scriptural precedent for only allowing congregational "veto" of candidates presented by existing elders?

17

News Item2/4/09 2:16 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Obviously, Neil if all or nearly all the men in a church are elder qualified, then they function as a governing body in a small church. I would suppose they could justly pick the leadership. At IHCC, they stopped congregational involvement many years ago. The old elders picked the new ones with the congregation may point out why a man isn't qualified. It's something like passing the bar for secular judges. This has work very well in IHCC case, which has kept doctrinal purity for a long time. I in other instances at other places, it could keep error in place or let it slowly seep in, but not as fast as a congregational setting. I see no place where democratic rule is sanctioned in governing a church body.

Of course the final responsibility rests on the individual. If he believes that his church is not biblical in major theological area, and the elders show no sign of changing their minds -- then he should jump up -- and leave. [URL=http://www.ihcc.org/article_print.php?art_id=Xp8yadWJKsjgjlfo05fgK3q7H]]]IHCC Statement of Faith[/URL] and [URL=http://www.ihcc.org/article_print.php?art_id=ewuUDRugbdehfzCkikDzX7W1D]]]IHCC Constitution[/URL]

16

News Item2/3/09 3:16 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
Jim, at least you got back to Scripture now, but there's a little problem with your reply: Titus & Paul are in Heaven. Who chooses now?

The RCC "solved" this problem with Apostolic Succession.

15

News Item2/3/09 2:52 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Actually, Fed Up, we're discussing, usually, the various news articles on here and sometimes there are no comments to some news articles. I admit sometimes many of us stray from the obvious, q.v., [URL=http://www.ihcc.org/images/booklets/pdf/L123.pdf]]]A Different Gospel: An Evaluation of the Teachings of Robert Schuller[/URL]. Even to the point, where for instance I don't even get your last point, Neil?
You mean there's suppose to be some democracy in picking church leaders? Not necessarily,

Titus 1
4 to Titus, my true child after a common faith: Grace and peace from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Saviour.
5. For this cause left I thee in Crete, that thou shouldest set in order the things that were wanting, and appoint elders in every city, as I gave thee charge;

The U.Meth. Church has quite a bit of democracy, but has more tares than wheat ruining that process. A congregational system, only works--and not flawlessly--because all men are flawed--when the congregation is Christian.

14

News Item2/3/09 2:15 PM
Fed Up | Belfast  Find all comments by Fed Up
Why do you all have to argue about EVERY single news item on this website?
13

News Item2/2/09 10:58 PM
On2wheels | Sydney  Find all comments by On2wheels
Judgment starts at the house of God. Only one thing thou? Is the Crystal Cathedral the house of Jesus I don't think so. Let Jesus stand true. Mybe Rev Rob don't have en'uf faith? Or lacks the hour of his power.
12

News Item2/2/09 2:59 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
So you let anecdotal experience overrule Biblical precedent.
11

News Item2/2/09 2:48 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Neil, if both the pastor and the board of elders are biblical they are going to get along, if they aren't they won't. Of course just because a leader and group gets along doesn't mean it's behaving biblically. I was on an administrative board of my local Methodist church, when I was a member of it. It usually got along with the minister, everyone accepted majority ruled (biblical action taken or not) It more or less functioned. I have seen enough of Church government, Methodist style, to never want to have a taste of it again. However, even the best of churches go the way of all flesh, either from internal or external influences. God doesn't guarantee local churches or denominations will continue, only that "His Church" will continue.
10

News Item2/2/09 2:37 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
"...I don't see any possibility that they wouldn't support each other."

I take from this that you have little experience in such situations.

Jim, from the rest of your remarks, it seems to me your view on church gov't is utterly pragmatic - if it works, it must be right; if it doesn't, it isn't.

I suggest consulting Acts & the pastoral epistles instead.

9

News Item2/2/09 2:28 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Well, you've made your stance very plain, now, Neil, and I can't make any mistakes on that again. (Well, I'm not getting any younger, so I'll probably make some mistakes somewhere. ) If the "head guy" and the elders are biblical, then I don't see any possibility that they wouldn't support each other? How are the elders to be picked? Besides having the qualities that are given in the Bible, that plus bible quizzes? Many times the congregation is not qualified to pick leaders. Sometimes head guys, elders, and congregations all drift along in the wrong direction. In that case I would say it is time for the Christian to pack up his bags and leave. Good right-headed leadership at the top rather than mob rule from the bottom seems to stave off decay, which is the fate of all human institutions including churches.
8

News Item2/2/09 2:18 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
Jim, I am in favor of family *integrated* churches (no age segregated worship or SS), not families establishing their own, private ones (except out of necessity).

Haven't I repeatedly advocated on these forums a plurality of elders as normative for church gov't (a real plurality, not mere henchmen for the Alpha male)? This only confirms my suspicion that you don't read posts carefully.

7

News Item2/2/09 2:11 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Neil, I had supposed, probably inaccurately, were in favor of family churches, which of course lack the oversight of elders. If I'm wrong about that, excellent! Family churches may have to exist from necessity, but are never the most desirable form of a Christian assembly.
6

News Item2/2/09 2:10 PM
Faithful Remnant  Find all comments by Faithful Remnant
I agree, Neil. Many today are referring to what a person says--"The Pope says....", "Pastor says.....", etc.
As for these mega ministries, it is no surprise to see them rise and fall when so much attention is given to one person.
5

News Item2/2/09 2:06 PM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
"a church leader does have much to do with setting the theology of an organization."

Yes, Jim, but *should* this be the case?

"Church government never supported anarchy. This is why..."

This sounds patronizing! Do you seriously think I believe otherwise?

4

News Item2/2/09 2:03 PM
Jim Lincoln | Nebraska  Find all comments by Jim Lincoln
Neil, a church leader does have much to do with setting the theology of an organization. Schuller of course is a particularity bad example of this, q.v., [URL=http://www.ihcc.org/images/booklets/pdf/L123.pdf]]]A Different Gospel: An Evaluation of the Teachings of Robert Schuller[/URL]. Church government never supported anarchy. This is why a system of elders was instituted to help with the running of a church.
Gil Rugh said or, wrote:
The church is God's household and he has set out clearly what are the qualifications of those who would exercise leadership in the church. There is no distinction of a clergy class, they are not better, they do not have more privileges or better access to God. It simply means that there is order in God's household. These qualifications should be true of every believer.
[URL=http://www.sermonaudio.com/sermoninfo.asp?SID=310410184]]]Biblical Household Management[/URL]
3

News Item2/2/09 10:45 AM
Neil | Tucson  Find all comments by Neil
"Members often tie their donations to the pastor, not the institution, said Nancy Ammerman, a sociologist of religion..."

I think she's correct. From what I've seen, most churches today are personality cults, like Rome. A good indication is how prominently the pastor's name is displayed.

2

News Item2/2/09 2:24 AM
Mark M. | GA in the Obamanation  Contact via emailFind all comments by Mark M.
I was never really a big fan of Schuller. I think he was a lot like Joel Osteen (sp?) in the way that he was good for drawing people to Christianity and presenting a positive message, but the program was clearly milk (or a milkshake) for "baby" Christians at best. I didn't watch enough to get the full picture of his philosophy, so anyone who wants can correct me if I am wrong. I always thought he went in to dangerous territory by denying real problems with "the power of positive thinking". I'm not a negative guy, I like cheerleaders like Joel, but when there are real problems it only hurts to deny them. The whole 'name it and claim it' thing is dangerous because we can't all be successful in this world. God loves poor people just as much as the rich. In this life time on Earth it is a very real possibility that you might not get to have an abundant life. Depending on where a person lives they might be lucky to eat every day. At the same time,we don't have to take a vow of poverty or be ashamed of the good things that we get to enjoy, but we should all keep in mind that God is here for everybody. This denial of reality may be one of the reasons why the Schullers have had such a hard time transitioning.
1
There are a total of 18 user comments displayed | add new comment |Subscribe to these comments
Last PostTotal
Religion Is on the Decline as More Adults Check ‘None’
john uk: "'christians make up 65% of the u.s. adult population...' :d"
-8 min 
Kim Kardashian, kids baptized as Kanye West confirms he 'got...
john uk: " youth in asia and so they repented, called on the name of the lord,..."
-13 min 43 
UAE Becomes World's First Country to Restore Iraqi Churches...
jim lincoln from nebraska: "youth in asia, from what i read from other sources ,..."
-2 hrs 



Dr. Andy Bloom
Steps To A Great Local Church

Psalm 119:105
Sunday - PM
Central Baptist Church
Play! | MP4 | RSS



Kevin Swanson
The Great Heritage of M. Henry

Generations Radio
Radio Broadcast
Play! | MP3

Stephen MacKenzie
Can Gays Be Saved?

Romans
Fishers of Men Bible...
Video!Play! | MP4

Sermon:
When Does Life Begin?
Kevin Swanson

SPONSOR | 14,100+

SPONSOR




                   
Mortification of the flesh is the true place of power in the Spirit. ... W. Kelly


Gospel of John
Cities | Local | Personal

MOBILE
iPhone + iPad
Church App
Watch
Android
Church App
Fire Tablet
Wear
Chromecast TV
Apple TV
Android TV
ROKU TV
Amazon Fire TV
Amazon Echo
Kindle Reader


HELP
Knowledgebase
Broadcasters
Listeners
Q&A
Uploading Sermons
Uploading Videos
Webcasting
Tips & Tricks
YouTube Screencasts
2-MINUTE TIPS

FOLLOW
Weekly Newsletter
Staff Picks Feed
SA Newsroom
RSS | Twitter | Facebook
SERVICES
Dashboard | Info
Cross Publish New!
Audio | Video | Podcast
Sermon Player | Video
Church Finder | Info
Mobile & Apps
Live Webcasting
Listen Line
Events Support
Transcription | PowerClips
Billboards | Biz Cards
Solo Sites
Favorites | QR Codes
Online Donations
24x7 Radio Stream
INTEGRATION
Embed Codes
Goodies
WordPress
Twitter
Facebook
Logos | e-Sword | BLB
JSON API

BATCH
Transfer Agent
Protected Podcasts
Auto-Upload Sermons
Upload via FTP
Upload via Dropbox
Picasa
ABOUT US
The largest and most trusted library of audio sermons from conservative churches and ministries worldwide.

Our Services | Articles of Faith
Broadcast With Us
Earn SA COINS!
Advertising | Local Ads
CONTACT
info@sermonaudio.com
Privacy Policy | Support Us | Stories