members, click to sign in..
 
SITE NOTICE | MORE..
Bible Readings in App. You can now listen to the reading of the Bible using our iPhone or Android Apps. Simply go to the Sermons by Bible section and you'll see the new "Bible Audio" item with any Book and Chapter. Enjoy!
 


3,293 active users!!Bandwidth
SUNDAY
MAY 24, 2015
Home
NewsSITE
Events & Blogs
New Audio & Video
BroadcastersNew Stuff!
Local Church Finder
Webcast LIVE NOW!
Sermons by Bible
Sermons by Topic
Sermons by Speaker
Sermons by Date
Staff Picks
CommentsALL -21 min
Top Sermons
VideosPDFs
Daily Log
PhotosNew Stuff!
Stores
Online Bible
Hymnal
Daily Reading
About | 8 Days Left!
Submit Sermon
Members Only

Podcast + Codes
Sermon Browser Info | Demo
Newest Widget | Demo
Our Picks | Info | Demo
Latest Blog | Info | Demo
Single Sermon | Info
To embed a single sermon,
use the "Email & Share" button.
Mobile Apps | Info
Enjoy sermons from this broadcaster
on a variety of mobile devices.
MyChurch: allsaintsreformed
Church Apps | Info
Creating your own Church App is
as simple as turning ON the option.
All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church
John Sawtelle  |  Brea, California
Email Us!Our Website
Our Blog
Blog
Post+
Search
  
Filter By

Calvin on Deuteronomy 22:5 and Bruce Jenner's "transition"
TUESDAY, APRIL 28, 2015
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
In reading the headlines about Bruce Jenner's recent announcement about his decision to "transition" from being a man to a woman, I got to thinking if Calvin had any advice for contemporary Christians about how to evaluate such a decision. To seek a perspective on this, I turned to Calvin's comments on Deuteronomy 22:5 which says, "A woman shall not wear man’s clothing, nor shall a man put on a woman’s clothing; for whoever does these things is an abomination to the Lord your God." On this text Calvin says,

This decree also commends modesty in general, and in it God anticipates the danger, lest women should harden themselves into forgetfulness of modesty, or men should degenerate into effeminacy unworthy of their nature. Garments are not in themselves of so much importance; but as it is disgraceful for men to become effeminate, and also for women to affect manliness in their dress and gestures, propriety and modesty are prescribed, not only for decency's sake, but lest one kind of liberty should at length lead to something worse. The words of the heathen poet are very true: [97]

"What shame can she, who wears a helmet, show, Her sex deserting?"

Wherefore, decency in the fashion of the clothes is an excellent preservative of modesty.

As you can see from these comments, Calvin thinks this ancient OT text has something to say to our modern situation regarding the idea of a man dressing like a woman, and beyond that, perhaps even to a man "transitioning" from one gender to another. Not only does Calvin argue that it is disgraceful for women to "affect manliness" either in gesture or dress, he also claims to find support for his view in an unnamed "heathen" poet who affirmed that it is shameful for a woman to dress like a man. Beyond applying this commandment to apparel, Calvin applies it to gender deportment, conduct, and demeanor as he argues that it is disgraceful for men "to become effiminate" as it is "unworthy of their nature" having been created by God as a men.

It is interesting to compare Calvin's comments on this text to older and newer commentaries. Some older commentators include Matthew Henry and Matthew Poole. Both agree that this text continues to have binding authority under the New Covenant. Poole here says, this is forbidden, partly for decency sake, that men might not confound, nor seem to confound, those sexes which God hath distinguished, that all appearance of evil might be avoided, such change of garments carrying a manifest umbrage or sign of softness and effeminacy in the man, of arrogance and impudency in the woman, of lightness and petulancy in both." Matthew Henry's comments are similar as he explains, "The distinction of sexes by the apparel is to be kept up, for the preservation of our own and our neighbour’s chastity." Obviously both of these Reformed commentators agree with Calvin's interpretation that this commandment is not just for the Old Covenant dispensation, since it states a moral principle which has binding validity on account of its being grounded in the creation order.

Interestingly, newer commentators (19th century) hold the same view. Keil and Delitzsch can be taken to stand for new commentators and they hold the same line found in Calvin as they expound the meaning of this text when they say, "the divine distinction of the sexes, which was kept sacred in civil life by the clothing peculiar to each sex, was to be not less but even more sacredly observed." What is more, they don't hesitate to venture into making a broader application of this text as they go on to explain, "The immediate design of this prohibition was not to prevent licentiousness, or to oppose idolatrous practices (the proofs which Spencer has adduced of the existence of such usages among heathen nations are very far-fetched); but to maintain the sanctity of that distinction of the sexes which was established by the creation of man and woman, and in relation to which Israel was not to sin. Every violation or wiping out of this distinction—such even, for example, as the emancipation of a woman—was unnatural, and therefore an abomination in the sight of God."

Our takeway from these brief observations about Deuteronomy 22:5, found in Calvin's comments upon this text and in other well-regarded Protestant commentators, is that historic Reformed interpretation of this commandment indicates it has an ongoing application under the New Covenant. More than that, Calvin and subsequent commentators such as Henry, Poole, and Keil and Delitzsch, argue that the prohibition against cross-dressing, is not rooted in a peculiar cultural situation, rather, the prohibition is rooted in the unchanging nature of God's ordering of creation.

It could be argued that it is open for discussion whether Deuteronomy 22:5 addresses the matter of gender reassignment surgery, but, based upon the interpretation and application of this command by Calvin and leading Reformed commentators, it does not appear that any doubt exists as to whether it addresses the subject of cross-dressing. While there may be some question regarding what precisely constitutes a man wearing a woman's clothes, there is no question about the principle which Deuteronomy 22:5 seeks to address which is that both men and women are under a sacred obligation to maintain and uphold gender distinctions in their clothing and external deportment.

Category:  Theological Matters

permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »
Text feature this blog entry

     PAST BLOG ENTRIES     

Calvin on Deuteronomy 22:5
TUESDAY, APRIL 28, 2015
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
In reading the headlines about Bruce Jenner's recent announcement about his decision to "transition" from being a man to a woman, I got to think if Calvin had any advice for Christians about how to evaluate such a decision. To seek a perspective...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »


The Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody: The Dutch Reformed Church Pt.1
MONDAY, JANUARY 28, 2013
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
2 user comments
In 1835, Hendrik DeCock, a minister and leader of the 19th centurySecession churches of Holland, wrote a pamphlet against the use of uninspired hymns in public worship entitled, The So-Called Evangelical Hymns the Darling of the Enraptured and...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »


The Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in the Reformed and Presbyterian Churches, Pt 4
WEDNESDAY, MAY 30, 2012
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
2 user comments
The German Reformed Church In the post that introduced this series on the Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in the Reformed and Presbyterian churches, reference was made to an article which caught my attention many years ago when...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »


The Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in the Reformed and Presbyterian Churches, Pt 3
WEDNESDAY, MAY 02, 2012
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
The Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in Geneva The following quote from Louis Benson will help reset the topic in this series of posts on the classical Reformed and Presbyterian commitment to exclusive canonical psalmody in worship, and...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »


The Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in the Reformed and Presbyterian Churches, Pt 2
WEDNESDAY, MARCH 28, 2012
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
The Rise of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in Geneva It is a claim beyond dispute that the Reformed church in Geneva during the 16th century sang only inspired canonical psalms. Support abounds for this assertion, but perhaps the easiest way to...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »


The Rise and Decline of Exclusive Canonical Psalmody in the Reformed and Presbyterian Churches, Pt 1
WEDNESDAY, MARCH 14, 2012
Posted by: All Saints Reformed Presbyterian Church | more..
A Brief Introduction Early on in my seminary days as I was researching the Reformed regulative principle of worship and its classical application, I came across an article which grabbed hold of my attention: We Used to Sing Only Psalms; What...
[ abbreviated | read entire ]
permalink | post new | clone this | rss feed | blog top »




Rev. John Greer
Overcoming Worry & Wickedness

Motto Text for 2002
Sunday - AM
Ballymena Free Presbyterian
Play! | MP3 | RSS




Pastor Chalan Hetherington
Lord's Day - Morning Service

Lord's Day Services
Wattisham Strict Baptist...
Play! | MP3

Jon Couch
Look To God: Part 1

This Day Ministries
Radio Broadcast
Play! | MP3

E. A. Johnston
Lost Generation

Evangelism Awakening
Teaching
Transcript!Play! | MP3

Sponsor:
All Christians Must Be Sterilized!

Hindu Leader Decl­ar­es: All Chr­ist­ians Must Be Ster­il­ized To Destroy Their Pop­ul­at­ion!
www.puritandownloads.com/ma..

Sermon:
Who is the Old Self?
Ron Lewis

SPONSOR | 1,300+

SPONSOR




                   
Keep the truth and the truth will keep you. ... William Bridge

City: Las Vegas, NV
Gospel of John
Cities | Local | Personal
MOBILE
iPhone + iPad New!
Church App
Android New!
Church App
Kindle + Nook New!
Chromecast TV
ROKU TV
BlackBerry
Windows Mobile
Apple Watch New!
Pebble Smartwatch
Kindle Reader


HELP
Knowledgebase
Broadcasters
Listeners
Q&A
Uploading Sermons
Uploading Videos
Webcasting
Tips & Tricks
YouTube Screencasts

FOLLOW
Weekly Newsletter
Staff Picks Feed
Site Notices New!
RSS | Twitter | Facebook
SERVICES | ALL
Local Church Finder | Info
MP3 Play & Download
Mobile Apps
Podcasting
Video Support
Live Webcasting
Transcription Service
Business Cards
SOLO | MINI Sites
Domain Redirect
Favorites
QR Codes
24x7 Radio Stream

INTEGRATION
Sermon Browser
HTML Codes
WordPress
Twitter
Facebook
Logos | e-Sword New!
JSON API New!

BATCH
Transfer Agent
Protected Podcasts
Upload via Email
Auto-Upload Sermons
Auto-Blog Import
Picasa | FTP | Dropbox
ABOUT US
SermonAudio.com is the largest library of audio sermons from conservative churches and ministries worldwide. All broadcasters must adhere to the Articles of Faith.

Our Services | Testimonials
Broadcast With Us!
Support Us
Advertising | Local Ads
CONTACT
info@sermonaudio.com
Copyright © 2015 SermonAudio.com.